Bettinardi vs. Scotty Cameron — Golf Coach’s Advice

As the lead golf coach over at Tell Me More Golf, I often find myself answering a recurring question from my students: which putter should they invest in?

Unsurprisingly, Bettinardi and Scotty Cameron are the top contenders in the high-end putter game. Both brands boast a rich history of crafting top-notch putters for pros and amateurs.

But deciding between these two giants can be overwhelming, particularly for those new to the golfing world.

So, in this piece, we’ll dive into the nitty-gritty of what sets Bettinardi and Scotty Cameron putters apart, guiding you toward making a well-informed choice for your new putter.

Scotty Cameron Vs. Bettinardi Putters Compared

It’s no secret that Scotty Cameron and Bettinardi are two of the most beloved putter brands in the golfing community. 

Both are renowned for their exceptional quality and performance. Still, there are some distinctions that you should keep in mind when deciding between them.

For instance, Scotty Cameron putters are acclaimed for their distinct milled faces that ensure a smooth, even roll. In contrast, Bettinardi putters are known for their softer touch on the ball and greater forgiveness when putting.

It’s worth noting that Scotty Cameron putters tend to be pricier and offer fewer classic designs compared to Bettinardi. However, they enjoy a higher popularity among golfers. They are often regarded as some of the best putters available in the market.

Scotty Cameron Pros

Scotty Cameron putters have earned a stellar reputation among both pro golfers and hobbyists thanks to their outstanding craftsmanship and one-of-a-kind design features.

Here’s a rundown of the benefits you can enjoy with Scotty Cameron putters:

• Their distinct face milling ensures a consistent roll every time
• Top-notch craftsmanship and design are at the core of their appeal
• Highly favored by professional golfers and enthusiasts alike
• It offers a firm and straight feel, perfect for precise and technical putting strokes
• It boasts exceptional weighting and balance, granting enhanced control over the ball
• An extensive array of Scotty Cameron models to choose from, featuring popular series such as:
  • Scotty Cameron Newport 2
  • Scotty Cameron Phantom X

A mainstay on the PGA tour, frequently used by elite players like Tiger Woods and Justin Thomas.

Scotty Cameron Cons

Despite the high praise for Scotty Cameron putters, they come with a few drawbacks that potential users should be aware of.

Here are some of the cons associated with using a Scotty Cameron putter:

• Pricier compared to other putter brands, such as Bettinardi
• Less forgiving than some alternatives, which could be a challenge for most golfers
• Offers fewer classic design options compared to other brands
• Not the best choice for those who prefer a softer feel on the ball during putting
• It might not be the perfect fit for golfers seeking a high MOI putter to enhance their gameplay
• The premium price tag may not be suitable for those with budget constraints
• Potentially limited customization options compared to other putter brands

Bettinardi Pros

Bettinardi putters have gained a solid reputation for their top-notch craftsmanship, timeless designs, and superb feel and sound.

Here’s a list of the benefits that come with using a Bettinardi putter:

• Classic designs that cater to traditionalist golfers
• High-quality craftsmanship featuring meticulous attention to detail and precision milling
• Exceptional feel and sound, offering a soft feel on the ball
• More budget-friendly compared to some premium putter brands, such as Scotty Cameron
• Ideal for those who prefer a softer, more forgiving strike on the ball
• An excellent choice for golfers in search of a high MOI putter to elevate their game
• Enjoyed by professionals and amateurs alike, boasting a loyal fan base among golf enthusiasts

Bettinardi Cons

Although Bettinardi putters are highly regarded for their top-notch craftsmanship and timeless designs, they have a few downsides.

Here are some of the cons associated with using a Bettinardi putter:

• Fewer options compared to certain premium putter brands, like Scotty Cameron
• Not as popular as some other high-end putter brands, which could lead to a lower resale value
• It might not be the ideal choice for golfers who prefer a firmer feel on the ball during putting
• Potentially limited customization options compared to other brands, which may restrict personalization choices
• It may not boast the same degree of technological advancements as some other premium putter brands

Scotty Cameron Vs. Bettinardi For Beginners

Picking the perfect putter can be challenging, particularly for those new to golf. When comparing Scotty Cameron and Bettinardi putters, it’s crucial to consider the pros and cons of each brand, your personal preferences, and your budget.

Scotty Cameron putters are well-known for their distinct milled faces and precision. In contrast, Bettinardi putters deliver a softer touch on the ball and enhanced forgiveness.

Moreover, Bettinardi putters are more affordable than Scotty Cameron, making them a fantastic choice for beginners embarking on their golfing adventure.

Ultimately, testing out both brands to determine which putter offers the ideal feel and performance for your unique gameplay is highly recommended.

Scotty Cameron Vs. Bettinardi Quality

Scotty Cameron and Bettinardi are top-tier putter brands boasting remarkable quality and craftsmanship.

While each brand delivers exceptional putters, there are key differences to remember.

Scotty Cameron putters are renowned for their distinct milled faces and accuracy. In contrast, Bettinardi putters provide a softer touch on the ball and improved forgiveness.

Typically, Scotty Cameron putters come at a higher price point. Still, they feature a wider array of options and customization features.

Bettinardi putters, conversely, are more budget-friendly and showcase classic designs.

Ultimately, both brands are fantastic choices for golfers searching for durable, high-quality putters that stand the test of time.

Scotty Cameron Vs. Bettinardi Price

Price plays a crucial role when comparing Scotty Cameron and Bettinardi putters. Generally, Scotty Cameron putters come with a heftier price tag than Bettinardi putters, with some models reaching over $500.

The premium cost of Scotty Cameron putters reflects the brand’s exceptional craftsmanship, precision, and exclusivity.

On the other hand, Bettinardi putters, while still classified as premium putters, are often more budget-friendly than their Scotty Cameron counterparts, with some models priced below $300.

This price range is comparable to premium putters from well-established golf brands such as Titleist, Odyssey, Cleveland, Ping, Callaway, Mizuno, and TaylorMade.

Bettinardi Inovai Vs Scotty Cameron Phantom

The Bettinardi Inovai and Scotty Cameron Phantom are top-notch putters. Each offering features to help golfers enhance their strokes.

The Bettinardi Inovai boasts a classic blade-style design with a milled face crafted from high-quality stainless steel. It delivers a more traditional feel and comes in various finishes to match individual style preferences.

On the other hand, the Scotty Cameron Phantom features a mallet-style putter head with an expansive face made from a mix of materials like stainless steel, aluminum, and carbon fiber. 

In addition, the Phantom is engineered to provide greater forgiveness and can be customized in weight and configuration.

Ultimately, the choice between the two putters boils down to individual needs, playing style, and personal preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, Bettinardi or Scotty Cameron?

Whether Bettinardi or Scotty Cameron is superior depends on individual preferences, budget, and playing style.

Both brands are highly regarded and produce top-quality putters enjoyed by professional golfers and enthusiasts alike.

What is the difference between Scotty Cameron and Bettinardi?

The primary distinction between Scotty Cameron and Bettinardi putters can be found in their design, feel, and performance attributes.

Scotty Cameron putters are recognized for their distinct milled faces, which ensure a consistent roll, and cater to golfers who favor a firmer and straighter feel on the ball during putting.

On the other hand, Bettinardi putters deliver a softer touch on the ball, making them more forgiving and easier to control, particularly for those who appreciate a gentler touch.

Moreover, Scotty Cameron putters usually come at a higher price than Bettinardi putters and provide more customization and personalization options.

The choice between the two brands ultimately hinges on individual preferences, budget, and playing style.

Do any pros play Bettinardi?

Indeed, numerous professional golfers opt for Bettinardi putters. A few prominent Bettinardi pros are:

• Matt Kuchar
• Jason Kokrak
• Matt Fitzpatrick
• Fred Couples

Furthermore, Bettinardi putters have secured victories in multiple Masters tournaments, showcasing their prowess on golf’s grandest stage.

Why are Bettinardi putters so expensive?

Bettinardi putters rank among the pricier options on the market due to their outstanding craftsmanship and meticulous attention to detail.

The brand utilizes top-notch materials like stainless steel and carbon steel to produce putters that deliver superb feel and performance. 

In addition, every putter is skillfully handcrafted and milled, guaranteeing adherence to the brand’s rigorous quality standards.

The select range of designs and the brand’s exclusivity drive their price.

Conclusion

Bettinardi and Scotty Cameron putters each present distinct features and advantages to golfers seeking high-end putters to elevate their game.

Bettinardi putters are celebrated for their timeless designs and softer touch, giving golfers a more traditional and forgiving putting experience.

Conversely, Scotty Cameron putters are recognized for their innovative designs and uniform roll, offering golfers a more precise and technical putting experience.

Ultimately, the decision between Bettinardi and Scotty Cameron putters relies on individual preferences and playing styles.
The most effective way to find the ideal fit is to test various putters from both brands.

Patrick Corley

From a golf scholarship to a Southern California University, to a private golf coaching career and an instructor position at a nonprofit organization, I’m here to help you get better at golf! With my 50+ years of golf experience; I bring you Tell Me More Golf. A golf coaching website that helps your game with instructional golfing content that’s ultimately geared toward making you a better golfer and having more fun!

Our golf instructor team brings it all to you, so enjoy!

• LinkedIn
• Instagram
• Youtube