Best Putters For High Handicappers (Golf Coach's Advice)

Best Putters for High Handicappers via Tell Me More Golf Coaches and Instructors

As the leader of the Golf Coach team at Tell Me More Golf, I am making sure you make an informed buying decision; getting you our top list of the Best Putters for High Handicappers.

These 3 expert review guidelines are used by Tell Me More Golf’s Instructor review team for criteria on these putters:

  • Putter length
  • Putter design
  • Balance point

#1. TaylorMade Spider Putter – The Most Forgiving Putter

TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3, Right Hand, 35 IN

TaylorMade is no longer just known for golf clubs. This high MOI putter helps high-handicappers with distance control on long putts while providing better alignment on short putts.

The Pure Roll insert is designed to generate topspin which also helps to get the golf ball rolling on its intended line.

The Benefits:

TaylorMade putters quickly became known for their quality and consistency. While the TaylorMade Spider is a forgiving mallet putter, it is also used at the highest level of golf. Dustin Johnson used a version of this putter to win the Masters, so you know it is worth a second look.


  • Large sweet spot
  • Forgiving club head
  • High-quality face insert


  • Head shape is smaller than many mallet putters and takes some getting used to but will help improve all types of putting strokes

#2. Odyssey Golf White Hot OG Putter – Best Alignment

Callaway White Hot OG Putter (Seven Nano, Right Hand, 33' Shaft, Steel Shaft, Pistol Grip)

Although this golf club is used by some of the best putters on the PGA Tour, our testing shows that it is also the best for high-handicappers. We came to this conclusion because of the level of forgiveness in the club head combined with the White Hot Insert. Most golfers can pick up and become comfortable with this type of putter.

The Benefits:

This is the best putter for high handicappers because it combines performance with a standard-looking mallet putter head. Like the Spider this also has a high moment of inertia which will help new golfers and high handicappers develop consistent distance control.

The soft feel will quickly bring a sense of confidence on the greens, which is why it is in our list showing you the Best Putter for High Handicappers.


  • Easy alignment
  • Proven face technology
  • Consistent roll


  • Can feel a bit lighter than other mallets but golfers will quickly adapt

#3. Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X – Best Feel

Titleist Scotty Cameron Phantom X 7 2022 Putter

It is hard not to fall in love with a Scotty Cameron putter. Between the quality of the build and the perfect balance, it feels like you can sink more putts just by putting this club in the bag.

This mallet with the wingback design will improve your game by helping with your alignment and distance control, making it one of the top Best Game Improvement Putters.

The Benefits:

In testing, we were able to clearly notice consistency on off-center hits. The traditional top lines easily get the golf ball started in the right direction. If you are a high handicapper and your putting is holding you back, this is the right putter for you.


  • Stainless steel design
  • Large sweet spot
  • Tour-proven head design


  • This putter is on the pricey-side of the bunch


#4. Ping Anser Putter – Best Blade Putter for High Handicappers

Ping 2023 Anser Putter

Putting strokes are as unique as golf swings. Some golfers take the club straight back and straight through, while others putt on an arc. As a more traditional putter shape, the Ping Answer is a great putter for either method.

The Benefits:

Ping has milled the face of the putter which is designed to help get the ball rolling end over end. It also has a softer face insert in addition to the milled face, which will inspire confidence. This is not a mallet-style putter but will have similar forgiveness on mishits to the mallet putters we’ve identified.


  • High MOI
  • Milled face
  • Good for arc strokes


  • Slightly less forgiveness than a mallet style

#5. Cleveland Huntington Beach

Cleveland Golf HB Soft #11 Single 35' OS, Satin, Huntington Beach Soft

During my brief mini-tour career, I had a chance to rep for Cleveland/Srixon. In my opinion, it is the most underrated brand in golf. Specifically, I played this putter and come here with a personal tournament-tested review. 

This putter inspires confidence immediately and comes with a larger grip which can help beginners and those that use too much wrist in their stroke, making it to the list as being a Best Putter for Beginners.

The Benefits:

The larger grip helps to force a golfer to rock their shoulders, which is a good technique. The head has a setup with a large alignment line and two wingbacks to increase forgiveness.

The precision-milled face will get your ball rolling on its intended line. This is one of the best all-around putters in the game and one of the best values in the world of putters.


  • Soft feel
  • Easy to align
  • Great balance


  • The grip may take some getting used to but can be replaced easily if the golfer chooses

How to Choose the Best Putter for a Beginner – Buyer’s Guide

Best Putters for High Handicappers with The Balance Point and Other Guidelines for Purchasing Golf Putters

Putter Length

The length of your putter is so vital. So many amateurs will pick a putter based on the look or grip, or another variable that they feel is key. 

Having the proper putter length can be one of the fastest ways to lower your scores. The right putter length allows golfers to connect with the ball at the bottom of the arc of their stroke, which means they are going to hit the sweet spot more often. To find the right length on your own, test out a putter with one hand. If you are right-handed, putt with your right hand only.

If the putter bottoms out before you hit the ball, the putter is too long. If you hit a putt thin, the putter is too short. Try this test with several putts of varying lengths to determine the right length.

Putter Design

The design of a putter head is there for 2 main reasons: 

1) to instill confidence that you will hit the sweet spot

2) to align to the type of stroke you make. 

The simplest way to tell what type of stroke you make is to put two clubs or alignment sticks parallel to each other about putter width apart. Take some practice strokes and notice where the putter head stops following those tracks. 

If it leaves the tracks quickly, you have a strong arc; if it tends to stay close to the tracks, you have a straight back and straight-through stroke. Make sure your putter aligns with your current stroke or the stroke you are looking to achieve.

Balance Point

The balance point on a putter is where the putter will not wobble when you have one finger holding it up. That is the easiest test. The balance point is important because it helps you to release the putter consistently. 

Look for a putter that has a balance point a little further away from the head as a beginner. This will help you get used to having a proper release in your putter.


Patrick Corley Tell Me More Golf Instructor and Coach
Patrick Corley
From a golf scholarship to a Southern California University, to a private golf coaching career and an instructor position at a nonprofit organization, I’m here to help you get better at golf! With my 50+ years of golf experience; I bring you Tell Me More Golf. A golf coaching website that helps your game with instructional golfing content that’s ultimately geared toward making you a better golfer and having more fun!
Our golf instructor team brings it all to you, so enjoy!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Tell Me More Golf Browser Icon Theme for Website


Tell Me More Golf Instructor Free Golf Tips Coaching Advice and Expert Instructional Courses for Free